Archive for the ‘property rights’ category

Land titles necessary, but insufficient

September 11th, 2006

I wrote previously about an insightful book by Hernando de Soto called The Mystery of Capital which argues for the importance of legitimizing land rights for the poor as a key in breaking poverty. By not having legal right to property, the poor people’s property is effect “dead capital” as it cannot be used as collateral, sold or inherited.

The Economist recently published an article called The mystery of capital deepens which follows the progress of an interesting land rights situation in Argentina. On the outskirts of Buenos Aires, a number of squatters outlasted various governments until a new government expropriated the land and gave it to the squatters. But some of the squatters didn’t like the terms, so there are now two groups side-by-side — land owners and squatters.

Summary of results: [Here is a more in-depth study.]

  • secure land rights encourage the poor to improve their residences/living conditions
  • [poor] titled landowners have no better access to financial services

This demonstrates the continued need for alternative financial services for the poor — e.g. microfinance. The large, traditional bank sector continues to have little appetite for serving the poor.

The Mystery of Capital book review

July 7th, 2005

The Mystery of Capital: Why Capitalism Triumphs in the West and Fails Everywhere Else

by Hernando Desoto

I think it is pretty much unanimously agreed to by most economists that in order to unleash the full potential of the wealth creation process of capitalism that a nation needs to have a reasonable and predictable methodology for defining and managing property rights.

I highly recommend Hernando de Soto’s book, The Mystery of Capital (subtitle: Why Capitalism Triumphs in the West and Fails Everywhere Else), where he explores the history of property rights in the developed world and the state in developing world nations. He argues for the essential nature of well-defined property rights to transform the trillions of $ of “dead capital” (property which is owned through the unofficial “extra-legal” market) into leveragable capital which we take for granted in the developed world. One of the most interesting sections is when he describes the extended time (75+ years) it took in USA for property rights to become reasonably established. He argues that we expect developing nations to implement our current system in a very short period of time which isn’t the process the USA (and all other developed nation systems) went through! It is inherently a political process and politics takes time for new systems to soak into the fabric of the society and displace the entrenched status quo which has many beneficiaries.

Related Posts with Thumbnails